OPINION: City should offer olive branch to Horton

When the after-effects of Hull City’s top-tier spendthrift era took hold, there were a few innocent victims in it all. We sold Michael Turner, our finest footballer, because the club was suddenly desperate for cash. Boaz Myhill left, in tears, for peanuts because every last offer for our players had to be accepted. And, when Phil Brown was put on gardening leave, his assistant Brian Horton also left the club. This has left a slightly sour taste with City fans to this day, but is there now a chance to remedy it?

Horton, thanks to his management of the club in the 80s and his return two decades later under Brown, is a Hull City legend twice over. Though he was Brown’s batman throughout the glory years and the fall from grace, as an old-school leader he never seemed to get involved in the politics or look to promote his own image. His ego was, and always has been, pretty much invisible. Throughout a distinguished managerial career, during which period he became one of the handful of gaffers to pass 1,000 matches in charge, he never set out to enhance his public persona. The only time he took flak was when Francis Lee took over as owner of Manchester City and the press immediately suggested Horton’s time in charge – the biggest job he would ever have – was now in peril as Lee would want his own appointment. Horton’s response was to ignore the catcalling and keep going, and then refuse to trust journalists after he was eventually given the boot. The club he left in a reasonable position was relegated under his successor, Alan Ball. Vindication, but in Horton’s case, just sorrow. Jobs further down the food chain followed – an ex-Manchester City boss in the top flight doesn’t later become manager of Port Vale or Macclesfield if he thinks he’s above them. He was about working with footballers and, admirably, nothing else.

His return to City as Brown’s number two was hailed unanimously. An avuncular but still tough presence, he could double up as saint or devil depending on Brown’s stance with a player, and had the backing of the supporters that saw some delightful football under his stewardship in the mid 1980s; his first managerial role which many still feel was ended impetuously. Brown had hired a Hull City man. Promotion to the Premier League followed and Brown was happy to credit him his share of the plaudits, as were we all.

As Brown’s antics and image in the top flight made him a comical figure, Horton remained resolute and stoic. He rarely gave interviews – Brown’s now legendary willingness to appear on screen and air made it largely unnecessary – and he got on with his job. Brown fell out with an ample number of players but Horton appeared not to do so. If ever there was a time when an experienced assistant needed to change his younger, progressive boss’s mind, it was when Brown needed to be persuaded to restore players on his naughty step. You can’t imagine Brown turning to George Boateng or Craig Fagan and offering to bury the hatchet without someone with real gravitas in his earhole telling him it was necessary. That was Horton’s job.

And so Horton also left the Tigers when Brown got banished to his allotment in March 2010. Though there was disappointment for Brown, the overriding emotions at his exit were surprise (as we’d just out-fought Arsenal with ten men) and fear (that his exit was little to do with football matches, and damaging revelations were on the way). But once it filtered through that Horton had gone too, it was just genuine sadness. No-one won. They lost their jobs, we were looking at losing our status and, more worryingly, our solvency, and on top of all that, Iain Dowie came in.

It took a while for negotiations over Brown’s final settlement to be agreed, and afterwards his battered image meant he was overlooked for some new jobs. Horton, just in his 60s, presumably still wanted to work. It’s not known whether he was deliberately waiting for Brown to secure a job and then go in with him, but nonetheless that’s what happened when Brown was given the job of managing Preston North End at the beginning of this year and took Horton along.

Now the two are out of work again – unfairly, it seems, but then again Peter Ridsdale is the football equivalent of Harriet Harman, someone whose ambition far outweighs their ability – and maybe there’s a new gig waiting for Brown. Hartlepool United have a vacancy, for example, and they are Brown’s old club, on his patch, they’re in the same division as Preston, and the Northern Echo have already mooted the idea. Wherever Brown goes next, you’d assume that Horton will still go with him. Unless, that is, Horton is offered the opportunity to be someone else’s assistant. Nick Barmby’s, in fact.

It makes so much sense. Barmby needs an old hand alongside him, someone who knows the club, the supporters and the gaffer himself. The club have publicly said they want to create a Hull-centric coaching set-up. Moreover, although the squad was conclusively overhauled after relegation, there are enough players in there with whom Horton has a working history – Andy Dawson, Richard Garcia, Paul McShane, Tom Cairney, Kevin Kilbane, plus others – and so he’d be hitting the ground running.

The question mark is how Horton is perceived by the club. Brown was sacked by Adam Pearson, which one assumes means Horton was sacked by him too. Their subsequent relationship is, presumably, a little strained, but while it’s far too romantic to suggest Brown could ever work with Pearson again (and, even if they were bezzie mates, I don’t think any of us could handle the soap opera that comes with Brown again), it somehow feels like Horton’s standing within the walls of the KC is salvageable. Barmby is a well-known admirer of Horton and has known him since he was a child, and needs the support of someone exactly like him.

If it is Pearson who blocks any prospect of Horton’s return, there is a form of consolation available. It would provide proof that Pearson still wields power and influence over the club, after many concerns expressed by supporters that he is being severely marginalised by the Allam regime. But it’s a hollow consolation in some ways; we don’t live in an ideal world, but if we did then Barmby would be banging down doors with bigger name-badges on than his demanding that Horton be approached, and bygones would be bygones between those that need them. Cast politics aside City, the man is decent, likeable, available and, more than anything else, he is ideal.

9 replies
  1. Chris
    Chris says:

    Agree fully, loved watching the Horton team of the past, his ideas will be similar to Nick’s and he would certainly lighten the load and offer a wealth of experience without undermining a younger manager in any way.
    Would be a good move so long as it didn’t involve any baggage from Browny.

  2. bartontiger
    bartontiger says:

    Well written article Matt but can’t help thinking if Horton is the experienced man City are looking at to help Barmby why didn’t the club just approach Preston to talk to him. I am sure football clubs don’t have to wait for people to become unemployed before they offer them a job.

  3. LewesTiger
    LewesTiger says:

    This article echoes my thoughts when I heard that Horton was suddenly available. Seems like Ridsdale has given the Tigers another boost after he gaves AP…Let’s hope we take the gift with both hands and indeed open arms.

  4. amberroar
    amberroar says:

    Matt, i admire your flair for being a witty and factual journo. but please…
    If Adam Pearson is the forward thinking, hungry for Tigers success individual i have him marked down as, he will roar with laughter if he happens upon this article.
    Is the club left with any player from Hortons days that will survive beyond this seasons contracts? Dawson and Garcia may be the only exceptions but will not feature regularly is my guess.
    Working history, do me a favour!
    We have a young squad playing better in the last five games under a young ‘caretaker’ than in the previous 18 months and the highest league position since relegation, why do we need to keep bringing back old mates with old ways of thinking, this team has no place for rose tinted glasses.
    Looking forward i wish Brian and Phil well in their next vocation but we are not where we are now from gazing in the wrong direction, Looking forward is what we should continue doing.
    And i also look forward to your next report Matt, but please, not after the pub mate…

  5. Neillo
    Neillo says:

    What a load of crap ! Just ask Chillo about about Mr Horton and you will learn about the true Mr Horton. His day has gone now, let Nick Barmby bring through fresh blood in the form of players and back room staff and put this club back on the map on a permanent basis, not just for fun

  6. Haitian Horace
    Haitian Horace says:

    Batman is a military term, meaning a lower-ranked soldier assigned to assist a senior officer.

  7. gjhdurham
    gjhdurham says:

    Not going to happen….Neillo, you need to explain that comment. Chillo & Waggy were known to like a pint or two, so if BH kicked some a***s then probably justified in my book! Ex-footballers; Some managers they like, some they don’t…can’t please everyone…

  8. Barry
    Barry says:

    What a load of crap ! Just ask Chillo about about Mr Horton and you will learn about the true Mr Horton. His day has gone now, let Nick Barmby bring through fresh blood in the form of players and back room staff and put this club back on the map on a permanent basis, not just for fun

    Interesting post, but the fact is if chillo has an agenda against mr. Horton then his views are not only tainted but bias.
    Anything Chillo has to say against Horton would be prejudiced and therefore should be taken with a grain of salt as they are then only assumptions, and we all what happens when someone uses assumptions to make a point, don’t we.

Comments are closed.